In today’s rapidly evolving business environment, innovation is often heralded as a strategic imperative. Yet, many C-level executives continue to struggle with one crucial element—seeing the return on investment (ROI) from their innovation initiatives. Having served as the head of innovation for a Fortune 50 company with over 20,000 employees, and later as a mentor to innovation leaders worldwide, I have seen this challenge up close. The disconnect between innovation efforts and clear ROI is one of the most frustrating and persistent problems in the corporate world. But it doesn’t have to be this way. In my experience, these challenges stem from a few key issues, but there are clear steps organizations can take to fix them.
The ROI Disconnect: Why It Happens
Misaligned Expectations - One of the first challenges I faced as a corporate innovation executive was helping leadership recalibrate their expectations. Innovation inherently involves experimentation, risk, and long-term investment. Many executives expect innovation to yield results as predictably as operational improvements, where you can measure success by immediate cost savings or efficiency gains. However, innovation doesn’t work in linear, predictable ways. It often requires years of incubation before it impacts the bottom line. As I’ve experienced, success often involves managing these expectations early on, helping leaders understand that the real payoff—whether it’s new revenue streams, market leadership, or operational breakthroughs—might take time​​.
Short-Term Focus Over Long-Term Value - One mistake I’ve seen repeatedly during my career is that innovation projects are evaluated through the same lens as short-term operational goals. C-level leaders may want to see ROI within the same quarter or fiscal year, causing them to dismiss projects prematurely. I’ve seen cases where promising initiatives were halted because they didn’t show immediate results. A short-term mindset can destroy the potential of innovations that could drive significant future growth. My advice to executives is to create a balanced portfolio of innovation initiatives—some with quick returns and others with longer horizons—and measure them accordingly​​. At the same time, innovation executives must take steps to ensure that such investments do not incur an unnecessarily high burn rate over time as the higher the burn rate, the shorter the runway of patience that executives will have.
Lack of Structured Innovation Processes - When I was tasked with launching a global innovation program, one of the first things I did was implement a structured framework for tracking and measuring innovation efforts. In too many organizations, innovation happens haphazardly. Teams are left to navigate on their own, leading to "innovation theater"—plenty of activity but little measurable impact. With no clear process, it becomes difficult for executives to see where their investment is going and what progress is being made. In my experience, establishing an Innovation Funnel that tracks each project through stages—validation, experimentation, business modeling, and deployment—ensures that every innovation investment is purposeful, managed, and assessed​​. A funnel allows for the gradual reduction of investment opportunities leaving only the most promising ones for last. The idea is not to form an innovation beaurocracy but simple to set clear rules and guidelines as to what is expected from ventures at each stage and what criteria they should adhere to in order to make it to the next.
How to Fix the Innovation ROI Challenge
Adopt the Right Metrics - One of the most valuable lessons I learned from leading a corporate innovation initiative is that measuring innovation solely through traditional financial metrics is a mistake. Instead, companies need to track progress-oriented KPIs. For example, when we began tracking the number of experiments, partnerships, and pilots in our program, it became easier to demonstrate tangible progress. Executives should also tie these metrics to strategic goals, such as entering new markets or improving customer retention, making it easier to measure the real value of innovation over time​​.
Build a Structured Innovation Funnel - I cannot emphasize enough the importance of having a clear, structured process for innovation. In my experience, executives often see innovation efforts as chaotic or disconnected. By implementing an Innovation Funnel, we were able to categorize projects at different stages of development and focus resources more effectively. This structure allowed us to weed out weak ideas early on and ensure that the projects that advanced to the next stages were backed by evidence and data, not just gut feelings. Having these clear stages—such as initial validation, funded experimentation, and deployment—provides a construct to follow and measure for both the innovators and the decision-makers​​.
Align Innovation with Strategic Goals - One thing I always stressed to my team was the importance of linking innovation to the company’s core strategy. If your innovation efforts don’t tie back to the company’s long-term goals, they will eventually lose support. In my role, I frequently communicated how specific projects aligned with revenue growth, operational efficiency, or market leadership goals. This strategic alignment not only made it easier to secure executive buy-in, but it also helped us avoid wasting resources on initiatives that, while creative, didn’t move the needle for the business​​.
Create an Innovation Culture Through Intrapreneurship - Intrapreneurship is not just a buzzword. In my time as an executive, I saw how powerful it can be when employees at all levels feel empowered to innovate. One of my proudest achievements was launching an Innovation Champions program that trained employees across departments to lead their own innovation projects. By empowering them and giving them the tools to succeed, we saw a surge in creative problem-solving, new venture creation, and ultimately measurable business impact. My advice to executives: Don’t rely solely on a central innovation team. Instead, foster a culture where every employee is encouraged to think and act like an entrepreneur​​.
Embed Innovation in Work Plans - During my time managing large-scale innovation efforts, one thing became clear: innovation should not be seen as a side project. To truly capture ROI, innovation must be embedded into the organization’s official work plans. We integrated innovation projects into the broader corporate strategy, making them part of our operational goals. This meant that even during turbulent times, such as budget cuts or organizational shifts, innovation continued to receive the attention and resources it needed to thrive​​.
A Final Piece of Advice from Experience
If there’s one thing I’ve learned in my years of leading innovation at the corporate level, it’s this: focus on validation, not just on building. In the early stages of any innovation initiative, the goal should be to validate the idea—whether through experiments, prototypes, or market tests—before committing substantial resources. Too often, organizations spend millions building something before they've validated whether it will work or whether customers will want it. Delaying judgment, controlling experiment costs, and focusing on learning before scaling is the key to reducing risk and maximizing innovation overall ROI​​.
In conclusion, the path to achieving real innovation ROI is not always easy, but it is attainable. By adopting the right metrics, creating a structured process, aligning innovation with strategy, fostering a culture of intrapreneurship, and embedding innovation into work plans, C-level executives can turn their innovation investments into measurable successes. I’ve lived through the challenges and the triumphs, and I can confidently say that with the right approach, innovation can move from being a frustrating mystery to a powerful driver of growth and competitive advantage.
Comments